Head to head · Sleep & Stress
Natrol Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets vs OLLY Sleep Gummies (Blackberry Zen)
Natrol and OLLY finish level in our scoring (7.8 vs 7.7), so the right pick depends on what you value most — Natrol is stronger on value and experience, OLLY on quality & purity and transparency.
Updated September 2026 from our full reviews · How we score
Cheap, strawberry-flavored melatonin that melts on the tongue. The best-selling 5 mg strength is more than most adults need; the 1 mg or 3 mg version is a smarter start.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — it never affects our scores. How we make money
NSF-certified gummy with a sensible 3 mg melatonin dose, but its L-theanine (50 mg) and botanicals are well below the amounts used in research.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — it never affects our scores. How we make money
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — it never affects our scores. How we make money
The short answer
Choose Natrol if…
- Occasional sleeplessness or jet lag
- People who dislike swallowing pills
- Budget-conscious buyers
- You care most about value, experience
- You want the lower cost per serving ($0.11)
Choose OLLY if…
- People who prefer a gummy to a pill
- Shoppers who want NSF-certified label accuracy
- Occasional sleeplessness and travel
- You care most about quality & purity, transparency
Key differences
- Biggest scoring gap
- Value: Natrol 8.8, OLLY 6.8. This factor covers cost per effective serving compared with category peers.
- Price
- Natrol costs $0.11 a serving, 80% less than OLLY ($0.56): about $3.30 versus $16.80 for 30 servings at the list prices in our reviews.
- Independent testing
- Only OLLY carries NSF Contents Certified; Natrol has no independent certification we could verify. NSF Contents Certified: NSF confirms the product contains what the label says and no harmful levels of contaminants.
- Melatonin
- Natrol lists 5 mg of melatonin per serving to OLLY's 3 mg, 1.7× as much.
- Formula
- Of the key ingredients in our reviews, only OLLY lists L-theanine.
- Format
- Natrol: tablet, 150 servings per container; OLLY: gummy, 25 servings per container.
- Flavors
- Natrol comes in 3 flavors, OLLY in 2.
- Dietary labels
- Only Natrol is labeled vegetarian, dairy-free and non-GMO. Only OLLY is labeled gluten-free.
Ingredients they share
Per serving, as each label lists it.
| Ingredient | Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets | Sleep Gummies (Blackberry Zen) |
|---|---|---|
| Melatonin | 5 mg | 3 mg |
Side by side
| Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets | Sleep Gummies (Blackberry Zen) | |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 7.8 / 10 | 7.7 / 10 |
| Efficacy (30%) | 7.2 | 7.0 |
| Quality & Purity (25%) | 7.3 | 8.6 |
| Value (20%) | 8.8 | 6.8 |
| Experience (15%) | 8.6 | 8.2 |
| Transparency (10%) | 8.0 | 8.3 |
| Form | Tablet | Gummy |
| Serving | 1 tablet150 servings per container | 2 gummies25 servings per container |
| Price per serving | $0.11 | $0.56 |
| Testing & certifications | cGMP facilityThird-party tested | NSF Contents Certified |
| Dietary | Vegetarian, Dairy-free, Non-GMO | Gluten-free |
| Key ingredients |
|
|
| Flavors | 3 (Strawberry, Citrus, Mint) | 2 (Blackberry Zen, Strawberry Sunset) |
| Creator video reviews | 4 | 5 |
Pros and cons
Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets
- About $0.11 per tablet at the brand's list price for 150 count
- Single-ingredient formula with no proprietary blend
- Dissolves in the mouth without water; buyers consistently praise the strawberry taste
- 5 mg is above the 1-3 mg range sleep experts commonly suggest; headaches are the side effect buyers mention most
- Label lists wheat and soy, so it is unsuitable for celiac disease or soy allergy
Sleep Gummies (Blackberry Zen)
- 3 mg melatonin per serving, within the range sleep experts commonly suggest
- Listed in NSF's certified dietary supplement database for label accuracy and contaminants
- Every ingredient amount disclosed, with no proprietary blend
- L-theanine (50 mg) and botanicals (16-17 mg each) are far below studied doses
- About $0.56 per serving at the brand's list price, roughly five times a basic melatonin tablet
Our verdict: Natrol vs OLLY
Natrol and OLLY are evenly matched overall (7.8 vs 7.7 out of 10), so the right pick depends on the differences above. Natrol is the value pick at 80% less per serving. Natrol gives more melatonin per serving (5 mg vs 3 mg). Each full review shows the evidence, testing and buyer feedback behind these scores.
What creators say
Questions people ask
Is Natrol better than OLLY?
Which is cheaper per serving, Natrol or OLLY?
Are Natrol and OLLY third-party tested?
Who should choose Natrol over OLLY?
What is the difference between Natrol and OLLY?
Which has more melatonin, Natrol or OLLY?
More sleep & stress comparisons
KSM-66 Ashwagandha Root Extract 600 mg vs Sleep Gummies (Blackberry Zen)
Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets vs KSM-66 Ashwagandha Root Extract 600 mg
Supercalm Calming Drink Mix vs KSM-66 Ashwagandha Root Extract 600 mg
Supercalm Calming Drink Mix vs Sleep Gummies (Blackberry Zen)
Melatonin Fast Dissolve Tablets vs Supercalm Calming Drink Mix
See all sleep & stress, ranked
