Head to head · Meal Replacements & Shakes
Huel Black Edition vs Orgain Organic Nutrition Shake
Huel scores higher overall (8.1 vs 7.1 out of 10), mainly on efficacy, quality & purity, value and transparency. Orgain still leads on experience.
Updated September 2026 from our full reviews · How we score
A complete vegan meal powder with 40 g protein, 11 g fiber and 27 vitamins and minerals per 400-calorie serving; fully disclosed, but the taste is divisive.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — it never affects our scores. How we make money
A USDA Organic, grass-fed dairy shake with 250 calories, 16 g of protein and 20 vitamins and minerals; closer to a light meal than most shakes, but low in fiber.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — it never affects our scores. How we make money
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — it never affects our scores. How we make money
The short answer
Choose Huel if…
- People replacing one or two meals a day with a high-protein option
- Vegans and those avoiding soy, lactose or gluten
- Shoppers who want every nutrient amount disclosed
- You care most about efficacy, quality & purity, value, transparency
Choose Orgain if…
- A light breakfast or lunch on the go
- Shoppers who want USDA Organic ingredients
- People avoiding artificial sweeteners and carrageenan
- You care most about experience
- You want the lower cost per serving ($3.00)
Side by side
| Black Edition | Organic Nutrition Shake | |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 8.1 / 10 | 7.1 / 10 |
| Efficacy (30%) | 8.7 | 7.0 |
| Quality & Purity (25%) | 7.8 | 7.0 |
| Value (20%) | 8.0 | 7.2 |
| Experience (15%) | 7.0 | 7.8 |
| Transparency (10%) | 9.2 | 6.5 |
| Form | Powder | Ready to drink |
| Serving | 90 g (about 2 scoops)17 servings per container | 1 carton (11 fl oz)12 servings per container |
| Price per serving | $3.53 | $3.00 |
| Testing & certifications | Third-party tested | USDA OrganicKosher |
| Dietary | Vegan, Gluten-free, Dairy-free, Soy-free, Non-GMO | Organic, Gluten-free, Soy-free, Non-GMO |
| Key ingredients |
|
|
| Flavors | 8 (Chocolate, Vanilla, Banana…) | 4 (Creamy Chocolate Fudge, Sweet Vanilla Bean, Strawberries & Cream…) |
| Creator video reviews | 4 | 3 |
Pros and cons
Black Edition
- 40 g plant protein and 11 g fiber per 400-calorie serving
- Complete nutrition panel and ingredient list published for every flavor
- Only 3 g added sugar; sweetened with stevia
- Around $3.53 per meal one-time, less on subscription
- Brand reports routine third-party testing for heavy metals and pesticides
- Taste and thick texture are frequent complaints
- Contains green tea extract and cocoa, so a small amount of caffeine
- No product-level certification such as NSF for Sport
- High potassium and phosphorus per serving may not suit everyone
Organic Nutrition Shake
- USDA Organic, with grass-fed milk and whey protein
- 250 calories plus 20 vitamins and minerals, closer to a light meal than most protein shakes
- No artificial sweeteners, carrageenan or soy ingredients
- 4.6-star average across more than 9,000 buyer ratings
- About $2.13 a shake when we checked
- Only 16 g protein and 1 g fiber per 250-calorie shake
- Sweetened with cane sugar and brown rice syrup, so it contains added sugar
- Not considered suitable for lactose intolerance, per Orgain
- Nutrition panel shown only as an image on the brand site; some buyers report lumpy or curdled cartons
Our verdicts
Black Edition
Huel Black Edition is one of the most complete and transparent meal powders you can buy, with 40 g of protein, real fiber and a full disclosed panel at a reasonable price per meal. Its weak spot is drinkability, not nutrition, so buy a single bag or variety box before committing to a subscription.
Full review
Organic Nutrition Shake
Orgain's Organic Nutrition Shake is one of the few best-selling shakes actually designed to stand in for a light meal, with 250 calories, a broad vitamin and mineral blend and USDA Organic ingredients. Its 16 g of protein and 1 g of fiber are modest, and it relies on cane sugar and rice syrup for sweetness. Buy it on Amazon, where it was far cheaper than on Orgain's own site when we checked.
Full review
What creators say
Questions people ask
Is Huel better than Orgain?
Which is cheaper per serving, Huel or Orgain?
Who should choose Huel over Orgain?
More meal replacements & shakes comparisons
Black Edition vs 30g High Protein Shake
Core Power High Protein Milk Shake vs Black Edition
Black Edition vs All-In-One Nutrition Shake
Core Power High Protein Milk Shake vs 30g High Protein Shake
All-In-One Nutrition Shake vs 30g High Protein Shake
Core Power High Protein Milk Shake vs All-In-One Nutrition Shake
See all meal replacements & shakes, ranked